One of those great articles that it’s difficult to quote from because I just want to quote almost all of it. But it makes the point that for all we constantly hear the refrain that the Israel/Palestine conflict is “complicated”, it’s really not complicated to understand that 700,000 Palestinians were violently expelled from their homes in 1949, that Palestinian-controlled territory has shrunk over time until it now consists of a ton of disconnected bantustans that still face constant raids and theft of resources by Israel, or that Palestinians living in Israel/Palestine are living under an apartheid regime, as is recognised by international human rights NGOs like Amnesty and Human Rights Watch, as well as Israeli ones like B’Tselem.
While violence against civilians is never “fair”, the article makes two points: Firstly, Israel works tirelessly to smother all non-violent forms of Palestinian resistance, including with violence, ensuring that violence comes to seem like the only option to some. It compares this to the ANC’s use of violence in the struggle against apartheid, which of course was used as an excuse by Western politicians of the day to back the racist apartheid regime, but is now recognised as a necessary evil – South Africa never would’ve been free without it. Secondly, the article points out that this “but they murdered civilians” argument is only ever levelled against those the Western media have deemed the Bad Guys, and never against those the media deems the Good Guys, even when these “Good Guys” are factually the ones murdering more civilians. In Israel/Palestine, the difference is orders of magnitude. Criticise Hamas’ attacks on civilians if you want, but you are a hypocrite if you haven’t also been criticising all of Israel’s violence against Palestinian civilians over the years. Plain and simple.
For my part, I do feel sympathy for Israeli civilians: it must be terrifying to live under threat of bombings, or to be abducted and held hostage while attending a music festival. But I have to put that sympathy in proportion to my sympathy for Palestinian civilians, who’ve been living with the threat of bombings, arbitrary arrests, violent assaults, and more for decades. The way forward cannot be for the Israeli regime to escalate the violence – it is for the abolition of apartheid and a new, pluralistic, truly democratic system to take its place. A number of Israelis do understand this, and I admire them for their tenacity because (unless they emigrate) they exist in a very hostile climate for such common-sense ideas. The majority of Israelis seem to believe they can avoid ever compromising with Palestinians by violently exterminating all resistance whenever it arises… which is clearly not a strategy that’s ever going to end well.